Hello Doc,

I have been offered a trade and I would like to get your thoughts. This is a keeper league and I have been offered QB Michael Vick (Phi) and RB Chris Johnson (Ten) for QB Cam Newton (Car), WR Julio Jones (Atl) and RB Fred Jackson (Buf). The part I like about my players is that they are young and I could have them for many years. The concern with those players is they are not proven or consistent yet. The players I am offered I like but Vick is injured often and CJ has not done much in a couple of years.

Answer: Keep who you have both Newton and Jones are likely to outlive the career of Johnson that’s just the way RB’s are chewed up in the NFL. CJ got his money now he doesn’t seem motivated something is off with him. Jones has great potential and will be a top 10 WR for the next 5-10 years. Keep the guys you have Vick takes too many hits.